How to Choose Books for a School Library in Nigeria: A Practical Checklist

A school library should not be a quiet room filled with books that pupils rarely open. It should help children discover stories, investigate unfamiliar subjects, improve their reading and develop the confidence to learn independently.

That outcome depends heavily on book selection. A title may be popular, affordable or educational without being suitable for a particular school. Administrators, teachers, librarians and parent committees therefore need a consistent method for deciding what to buy.

This checklist will help your school build or refresh a library collection with purpose.

1. Define what the library should accomplish

Begin with the needs of your pupils rather than a list of attractive titles. A clear purpose makes it easier to spend a limited budget wisely.

Your priorities might include:

• encouraging pupils who do not yet read for pleasure;
• supporting stronger comprehension and vocabulary;
• providing reference materials for classroom learning;
• introducing Nigerian and African experiences through stories;
• supporting personal development, creativity and practical skills;
• giving advanced readers more challenging material; or
• replacing worn, outdated or missing books.

A library can serve several purposes, but rank them before purchasing. If reluctant reading is the main problem, for example, accessible stories and visually engaging books may deserve more attention than dense reference works.

2. Review the collection you already have

Do not assume that an almost empty shelf is the only sign of a weak collection. A library can contain many books and still offer pupils too little useful choice.

Conduct a simple shelf review. Record each book’s subject, intended age group, physical condition, format and approximate difficulty. Note areas with too many similar titles as well as obvious gaps.

Look especially for:

• subjects represented by only one or two books;
• books that are too difficult for most pupils;
• damaged copies that can no longer circulate safely;
• old reference materials containing obsolete information;
• popular titles with too few copies; and
• age groups that have noticeably fewer options.

This review prevents unnecessary duplication and turns purchasing into a response to identifiable needs.

3. Match books to age, maturity and reading ability

Age labels can be helpful, but pupils of the same age do not always read at the same level. Some need short sentences and strong visual support, while others are ready for longer chapters and more complex ideas.

A balanced collection should provide an accessible starting point and room for growth. Consider sentence length, vocabulary, page density, illustrations, chapter length and the background knowledge required to understand the subject.

Also examine emotional maturity. A book may be easy to read while addressing themes that require careful adult guidance. Teachers or librarians should review the description and, where possible, a sample before making a large purchase.

4. Build variety into the collection

If every shelf contains only textbooks and examination materials, pupils may see reading as another assignment. If the collection contains only fiction, it may not adequately support research or practical learning.

A useful school library can include a considered mix of:

• picture books and early readers;
• short stories, novels and poetry;
• biographies and memoirs suitable for young readers;
• science, history, geography and technology books;
• faith, character and personal-development titles where appropriate;
• arts, crafts and practical skill books;
• dictionaries, atlases and other reference materials; and
• books for teachers and school leaders.

Variety should also exist within each group. Include books for quiet reflection, entertainment, discussion, investigation and project work.

5. Consider relevance without making the collection narrow

Nigerian pupils benefit from encountering recognisable names, communities, family experiences and social settings. Local relevance can make reading feel less distant and show children that their experiences belong in books.

However, relevance should not become isolation. Libraries also introduce readers to unfamiliar places, periods and perspectives. The goal is a collection that offers both recognition and discovery.

When assessing a title, ask whether it treats its people and subject with care. Avoid building a collection around books that depend on harmful stereotypes, careless factual claims or unnecessarily demeaning portrayals.

6. Inspect quality beyond the cover

A polished cover does not guarantee a suitable library book. Examine the content and production quality before ordering multiple copies.

Check for:

• clear and readable typography;
• appropriate illustrations and page layout;
• coherent organisation;
• sound editing and understandable language;
• accurate descriptions of the book’s purpose and audience;
• secure binding for frequently handled printed books; and
• legible reproduction without missing or blurred pages.

Minor imperfections may not destroy a book’s value, but repeated errors can confuse developing readers and make teaching more difficult.

7. Plan for durability and everyday use

A school book may pass through many hands. Think about how often a title will be borrowed, where it will be stored and whether younger pupils will use it without close supervision.

Durability is particularly important for high-demand stories, dictionaries, picture books and frequently consulted reference materials. A cheaper copy that needs rapid replacement may offer less value than a sturdier edition.

Schools should also plan basic care: dry shelving, clear borrowing records, sensible handling rules and a simple process for reporting damage. Good selection and good maintenance work together.

8. Decide how digital books fit into the plan

Ebooks can complement printed books when the school has suitable devices, reliable access arrangements and a clear supervision plan. They may be helpful for staff development, research or situations where several readers need convenient access.

Before buying a digital title, confirm its file format, device compatibility and permitted use. Do not assume that purchasing one ebook automatically gives unlimited access to an entire class.

Printed books may remain more practical where electricity, devices or screen access are inconsistent. Choose formats according to the school’s actual environment rather than novelty.

9. Invite pupils and teachers into the selection process

Circulation improves when readers can find books connected to their interests. Ask pupils what they enjoy reading, what they want to understand and which subjects feel missing from the shelves.

Teachers can identify recurring classroom needs, while librarians can report which books are frequently requested or abandoned. Suggestions should inform selection without replacing professional review.

The most requested book is not automatically the best purchase, but repeated requests are valuable evidence about reader interest.

A suggestion box, short class survey or termly discussion can provide useful information without making the process complicated.

10. Use a simple scoring sheet before purchasing

A scoring system helps a committee compare books consistently. Give each proposed title a score from one to five for the following criteria:

1. relevance to the library’s priorities;
2. suitability for the intended readers;
3. content and production quality;
4. likely level of pupil interest;
5. contribution to subject or genre balance;
6. durability or practical digital access; and
7. value in relation to the available budget.

A low score does not always mean that a book should be rejected. It may reveal that the title belongs in a classroom set, staff collection or older age section instead of the general library.

11. Buy in phases and learn from actual use

A school does not need to build the perfect library in one purchase. Start with the most urgent gaps, introduce the books properly and observe how pupils use them.

Track simple indicators such as borrowings, pupil requests, teacher feedback and the condition of frequently used books. These observations can guide the next purchasing round more reliably than assumptions.

Buying in phases also allows the school to adjust its priorities. If introductory science books circulate heavily while advanced titles remain untouched, the next order can respond accordingly.

A final checklist for the selection committee

Before approving a book, confirm that:

• its intended reader is clear;
• its difficulty suits at least part of the pupil population;
• its content supports an identified library need;
• it adds useful variety rather than unnecessary duplication;
• its language, facts and presentation have been reviewed;
• its format is practical for the school;
• its expected use justifies its cost; and
• the school has a plan for storing, lending and maintaining it.

A strong school library is built through deliberate choices, not simply a large order. Select books that pupils can enter confidently, grow through gradually and remember long after they leave the classroom.

Start Exploring Books for Your School

Browse the BestBooks catalogue to compare available books by subject, purpose and format. Review each title carefully against your school’s reading goals before creating a shortlist.

Browse the Book Catalogue